How we make brainstorming work
I would phrase the goal of brainstorming as generating many creative ideas quickly. I like the general idea, but I’ve often seen it fail to achieve this goal.
But, I noticed a pattern in the times that it worked exceptionally well:
-
Shannon Soper facilitated a sketching exercise for a product exploration at Gatsby that looked like this:
-
Everybody spends five minutes drawing a sketch of what they think the project in question could look like
-
Everybody presents their sketch in 2 minutes, and then it gets discussed.
-
Repeat
-
-
Teresa Torres introduced us at Stellate to her “brainwriting” technique, which looks like this:
-
Everybody spends two minutes writing down their ideas
-
Everybody comes back together, silently reads all the ideas, and then discusses for five minutes
-
Repeat
-
So, what’s the pattern? Multiple rapid rounds of divergence and convergence. (wet the drys, dry the wets, wet the drys, dry the wets, wet the drys,…)
The structure
The general structure of brainstorming sessions that work goes like this:
-
Silent writing: Everybody spends two minutes silently writing (or sketching or…) every single idea they can think of, going for quantity over quality
-
Review: We put all the ideas back together and spend two minutes reviewing the combined list of all the ideas
-
Discussion: We spend five minutes discussing the list, what thoughts different ideas sparked
- We’ve used comments in the combined list document (in Notion or Google Docs), which also worked nicely
-
Repeat: Go again. Repeat the whole cycle a few times.
Important guidelines
-
Quantity over quality: Participants must try to come up with as many ideas as possible, not focus on “good” ideas.
- Absolutely critical. I can’t overemphasize that enough. The second people think about quality at all, the whole thing starts breaking down.
-
Speed matters: keep each round short and sweet, and the facilitator needs to be moving the discussion along.
Why does it work?
-
By getting every person involved and focused on quantity over quality, you quickly generate a wide range of varied ideas.
- How to invent the future? By “getting more parts on the table.” Another way to look at this technique is that it helps us get more parts from more people on the table more quickly.
-
By coming back together and discussing the overall list, everybody can spot patterns and understand what they like and dislike
-
By repeating the process, everybody can copy what they like and put it together in new ways with other ideas
- “Where good ideas come from:” innovation happens by combining things we can see and touch today in novel ways
Other notes about Learning and/or Company Building
- 🌿How to be better at making decisions
What can I do before, during, and after making decisions to be better at making them?
- 🌿How I tend to my digital garden
My quests with this digital garden are to publish more and to have fun. Let's explore why I even have a digital garden and how it's going.
- 🌲1:1s are for personal connection, not project updates
My 1:1s are unusual. Here's why.
- 🌿How to present to executives
1. Know all your details Know and be able to speak to all the details. Review your own work and ask yourself what somebody else might ask you about it, then make sure you have a solid answer to all those questions. Even things that are technically ou...
- 🌿Developer tools startups are playing on hard mode
How do you build a business selling tools to people who can technically build anything you can?
- 🌲Being unreasonably responsive has made my projects more successful
Creators who respond to feedback quickly unlock two virtuous cycles that allow them to build better solutions more quickly.
- 🌱How to ship faster
Humans have the ability to get ambitious things done ridiculously fast. How can I get more things done quickly?
- 🌱How I manage my todos as a CEO
Kanban board with five columns: Inbox, Backlog, Blocked, Delegated, Done Most importantly: GTD-style “if it takes less than 2 minutes, do it immediately.” Create todos for everything (and I mean, everything, including replying to people) that go in...
- 🌿Message me whenever
Send me messages whenever inspiration strikes or when it makes sense for your workflow. I'll respond when I'm back online. This isn't about being "always on," quite the opposite: it's about respecting that we each know how to structure our own work l...
- 🔗Deliberate practice beats every other form of training, even via transfer learning
Many people are doing deliberate practice wrong in one specific way though. The Brazilians are an example of what happens when you get it right.
- 🌱How do you invent the future?
Innovation happens by combining things we can see and touch today in novel ways. So how can we have more things to see and touch?
- 🌱How to run recurring virtual meetings efficiently
Start with a checkin question for connection (10% of the meeting length) Capture decisions made Capture open action items and check in on open ones every time, otherwise they get lost/forgotten due to poor personal execution Align on discussion ...
- 🌿How I run gratitude circles
Credit to Sue Ko who taught me this many years ago. Gratitude circles are a beautiful way to get team members feel seen by their peers. I run them in-person at least once a year with each of my teams. Quote from one of my engineers after their first ...
- 🌿Why I don't compliment people for their talent
When people see somebody they perceive to be really good at something, they often say, “Wow, they are so talented!” I think that’s a bullshit compliment.
- 🔗David Cain: Do Quests, Not Goals
I love this reframing from "goal" to "quest": "goals" feel like pressure, "quests" feel like excitement and adventure!
- 🌿How we foster deeper connections in our remote team
I believe that teams that are more connected perform better and that remote teams have worse connections. How can we improve that?
- 🌲Why I'm vigorous about giving feedback
Every day, you will find me hunting down a founder's email to send them feedback about my experience with their product. Why?
- 🌱How I get things done
The smallest project management setup I need: visible workstreams, one accountable owner, deadlines, status updates, and fast weekly demos.